6.6
30 votes
Return to Amish

Return to Amish

TLC 2014

After leaving their sheltered Amish and Mennonite lives, Abe, Jeremiah, Kate, Rebecca and Sabrina experienced New York City together for the first time. Then, they traveled to Sarasota, Florida, in the series Breaking Amish: Brave New World. Now, with the exception of Kate, who’s living in New York and building her modeling career, the group has returned to Pennsylvania. Abe and Rebecca, still adjusting to married life, prepare to welcome a new baby into the family. Sabrina is also pregnant, but without the support of her Mennonite family, she’s on a difficult journey. Jeremiah has become an entrepreneur of sorts -- and is chasing love. Mary, Abe’s mother, struggles with being shunned by the community, and as her son Andrew is released from jail, he tries to start fresh with his on-again, off-again girlfriend Chapel and to mend his relationship with his family.

TV Reality Shows 551 Reality TV tvreality SubscriptionList fuboTV TV Shows MY REALITY TV Discovery+ PBS/TLC/DIY Shows

The 10 Worst Episodes of Return to Amish

#1 - Mary's Story

1.00

Season 4 - Episode 7

The episode was rated #1 Worst episode of Return to Amish from 1 votes.

#2 - Abe's Story

1.00

Season 4 - Episode 8

The episode was rated #2 Worst episode of Return to Amish from 1 votes.

#3 - Rebecca's Story

1.00

Season 4 - Episode 9

The episode was rated #3 Worst episode of Return to Amish from 1 votes.

#4 - Jeremiah's Story

1.00

Season 4 - Episode 10

The episode was rated #4 Worst episode of Return to Amish from 1 votes.

#5 - Sabrina's Story

1.00

Season 4 - Episode 11

The episode was rated #5 Worst episode of Return to Amish from 1 votes.

#6 - Come and Gone

1.00

Season 4 - Episode 12

The episode was rated #6 Worst episode of Return to Amish from 1 votes.

#7 - Donut Season

6.80

Season 5 - Episode 2

Jeremiah and Carmela introduce Lowell, Shelly and Dawn to the English world. Drama unfolds between Shelly and Lowell and threatens to ruin everyone’s time. Sabrina reacts to news of her father’s death. Mary wonders if the Amish community will welcome her back.

The episode was rated #7 Worst episode of Return to Amish from 15 votes.

#8 - Forgive Me, Carmela

6.80

Season 5 - Episode 6

Carmela agrees to meet Jeremiah and he apologizes for his behavior. No donuts will be sold today as they work through their issues, so Shelly uses the downtime to get a makeover. She wants to look English for her visit with her birth mother and also so she can go out on the town. She does not want to do anything permanent in case she wants to go back to being Mennonite. Afterwards she invites everyone to join her on a party bus. Sabrina gets sick again and goes to the hospital, and learns that she is pregnant and suffers a miscarriage. On her doctors' advice, she returns to Lancaster and enters a treatment program (and is doing well). Ada knows that Mary is the only one who can talk sense to Jeremiah and Carmela so she is invited to the house. Lowell tells his parents about Lisa's pregnancy and they are not happy about it. Mary takes a turn selling donuts and does very well. They pull up stakes and move to Nashville. Dawn feels comfortable there and gets a makeover, with Mary and Ada along for advice. Later her husband Keith shows up at the house and after some initial concern he decides to join Dawn as they all go out to clubs. They have a good time and Keith and Dawn rekindle their romance. All go their separate ways; Shelly intends to meet her birth mother.

The episode was rated #8 Worst episode of Return to Amish from 10 votes.

#9 - Going Full English

6.83

Season 5 - Episode 5

Despite initial success with the donut stand, tensions mount between Jeremiah and Carmela; Lowell decides to get a makeover; Mary must confront an Amish woman speaking out against her to the Bishop; Sabrina works at the donut stand.

The episode was rated #9 Worst episode of Return to Amish from 18 votes.

#10 - The DNA Test Request

6.88

Season 6 - Episode 4

The episode was rated #10 Worst episode of Return to Amish from 8 votes.

#11 - Jeremiah's Dark Past
6.90
Season 5 - Episode 4

Jeremiah faces challenges as he opens his donut stand for the first time; Mary attends church for the first time since returning home; Shelly debates whether she should contact her biological mother; Dawn wonders about going home.

The episode was rated #1 Worst episode of Return to Amish from 20 votes.

#12 - Sabrina's Surprise
6.91
Season 5 - Episode 3

Lowell, Shelly and Dawn rebel against Jeremiah's rigid rules and explore the English world; Mary must find a way to please the Bishop; Sabrina tries to make things right with Jeremiah; Jeremiah's temper creates problems.

The episode was rated #2 Worst episode of Return to Amish from 11 votes.

#13 - Broken Family
7.05
Season 2 - Episode 1

Mary continues to be shunned because she attended Andrew's wedding; Jeremiah and Katie Ann try to live by the rules; Kate's new look.

The episode was rated #3 Worst episode of Return to Amish from 37 votes.

#14 - Big Decisions
7.10
Season 2 - Episode 8

The episode was rated #4 Worst episode of Return to Amish from 20 votes.

#15 - The Panic in Amish Park
7.14
Season 6 - Episode 1

The pandemic has forced Jeremiah, Carmela, Ada and Sabrina together.

The episode was rated #5 Worst episode of Return to Amish from 7 votes.

#16 - Other Side of the Fence
7.17
Season 2 - Episode 5

The episode was rated #6 Worst episode of Return to Amish from 24 votes.

#17 - Leaving Everything Behind
7.22
Season 5 - Episode 1

Mary must decide if she will rejoin the Amish church; Jeremiah and Carmela make a risky decision to save their marriage; Sabrina must prove to Jeremiah that she's changed; Shelly, Lowell and Dawn decide to explore the English world.

The episode was rated #7 Worst episode of Return to Amish from 23 votes.

#18 - Rebel Without a Clue
7.30
Season 1 - Episode 6

Jeremiah makes a decision about his life; Andrew lets loose at his bachelor party; Chapel goes wedding dress shopping; Mary and Chester have unexpected news.

The episode was rated #8 Worst episode of Return to Amish from 27 votes.

#19 - I Got You Abe
7.30
Season 4 - Episode 2

Sabrina's home-birth plan may be in doubt when medical concerns are revealed; the stress of being new homeowners begins to take a toll on Jeremiah and Carmela's marriage; Rebecca continues with her GED classes; Mary and Abe take a trip to Florida.

The episode was rated #9 Worst episode of Return to Amish from 81 votes.

#20 - Dental Dilemma
7.30
Season 3 - Episode 3

The episode was rated #10 Worst episode of Return to Amish from 53 votes.

Last updated: apr 20, 2021

Search for TV shows...

About Me

I am Sophie and this is my website.

A little about me 👋 I am a marketing student in Paris. I love spending afternoons with friends in a cafe or a park.

But more than anything else, I love watching (.. binging…) series on my computer on rainy Sundays or any sunny day for that matter 🙈

I must have watched hundreds of shows by now, from romance to science-fiction series. Often I like to go back to a show I enjoyed. But I don’t feel like watching it all over again…

I created this website so myself and others could find the best episodes of our favourite shows. As of today, I have about 1,000 shows on the website with votes and rating coming from fans.

Hopefully, you can join me from your sofa and enjoy some nice TV!

- Sophie ☕️🍰