Worst Episodes
From Executive Producer Dick Wolf, this true crime investigative series follows veteran prosecutor Kelly Siegler, and her rotating team of seasoned detectives, as they travel to small towns across the country and help local law-enforcement agencies dig into unsolved homicide cases that have lingered for years without answers or justice for the victims due to lack of funding and proper forensic technology.
Written by Sophie and last updated on feb 10, 2023.
PS: The following content contains spoilers!
PPS: I will admit that parts of this page was written with the help of AI - it makes my work so much easier to not start from a blank page!
In Hope, Arkansas, Kelly and her team investigate the murder of a young mother who was brutally executed in her home. The clues to her killer’s identity may rest in the hands of her 10-year-old son who was in his bedroom at the time.
The episode was rated 7.79 from 108 votes.
Siegler and McClary travel to Cuero, TX., as they look to reopen a 2001 cold case and hope to discover if Pam Shelly was killed or if she committed suicide.
The episode was rated 7.78 from 160 votes.
Kelly and Yolanda travel to Arizona to comb for clues in the cold-case killing of a mother of two.
The episode was rated 7.73 from 83 votes.
The 2010 slaying of a single mother is investigated.
The episode was rated 7.70 from 64 votes.
Kelly and her team head to Oregon to investigate the mysterious disappearance of a man who vanished from home without a trace. There are seven suspects, missing gold coins and serious questions about what happened to Glenn Pennie.
The episode was rated 7.69 from 109 votes.
In part two of their investigation, the Cold Justice team continues to investigate three mysterious deaths in Wyoming, hoping they will be able to finally give answers to all the families involved.
The episode was rated 7.66 from 38 votes.
The Cold Justice team tackles the mysterious 1986 murder of a young Native American mother whose skull was found in the woods. Her infant daughter, now grown, is desperate to know if her father was involved.
The episode was rated 7.62 from 29 votes.
The Jasper County Sheriff's Department assist Kelly and Johnny Bonds as they sort through family drama and doomsday rumors to help a daughter unravel the mystery surrounding the 2012 disappearance of her 56-year-old mother.
The episode was rated 7.59 from 44 votes.
Siegler and McClary head to Gaines County, Texas, to search for new clues to help solve the 2008 murder of well-liked feed plant worker.
The episode was rated 7.50 from 80 votes.
A 21-year-old woman disappears after a late-night party, then her body is discovered years later in a nearby orange grove.
The episode was rated 7.46 from 41 votes.
