Catfish: The TV Show

10 Worst Episodes of Catfish: The TV Show

Nev and his co-hosts -- from Max to Kamie to celebrity guests -- help people in dubious online relationships track down their baes IRL so they can sort out what's fact and what's fiction.

Written by Sophie and last updated on feb 10, 2023.

PS: The following content contains spoilers!

PPS: I will admit that parts of this page was written with the help of AI - it makes my work so much easier to not start from a blank page!

Catfish: The TV Show - S4E5

#10 - Chitara & Priscilla (Season 4 - Episode 5)

A woman searches for answers when her relationship ends unexpectedly after she took a big leap and came out to her family.

The episode was rated 7.12 from 119 votes.

Catfish: The TV Show - S5E7

#9 - Ray & Lexi (Season 5 - Episode 7)


Ray is determined to finally meet his online love of four years, Lexi. But after learning that Lexi’s sister has meddled in the relationship in the past, Nev and Max soon find themselves with more questions than answers.

The episode was rated 7.12 from 214 votes.

Catfish: The TV Show - S5E19

#8 - Luis & Sydney (Season 5 - Episode 19)

Luis has fallen in love with a single mom who is down on her luck and now he's ready to take their online relationship to the next level. But first, Nev and Max must help investigate.

The episode was rated 7.10 from 246 votes.

Catfish: The TV Show - S6E19

#7 - Jose & Jay (Season 6 - Episode 19)


Jasmine writes to Nev and Max asking for help for a “friend.” But they’re perplexed when Jasmine drops a bombshell revelation: they’ve helped her friend before.

The episode was rated 7.08 from 182 votes.

Catfish: The TV Show - S6E13

#6 - Johnny & Connor (Season 6 - Episode 13)

After Jonathon’s online love disappears for a month, he enlists Nev and Max to help track him down. But when the guys discover a former catfish is involved, they begin to suspect Jonathon himself may be in on the deception!

The episode was rated 7.07 from 240 votes.

Catfish: The TV Show - S4E19

#5 - Brittany & Bryon (Season 4 - Episode 19)


When Brittany, a single mom, finds love online with Bryon, a marine who may get deployed again to Iraq, she seeks Nev and Max’s help before she runs out of time.

The episode was rated 7.05 from 115 votes.

Catfish: The TV Show - S4E1

#4 - Miracle & Javonni (Season 4 - Episode 1)

Smart, single mom Miracle fell hard for Javonni, a dreamy-eyed Instagrammer. With Max on hiatus, Nev teams up with TV personality Charlamagne to take Miracle on a hunt for the man of her dreams

The episode was rated 7.00 from 108 votes.

Catfish: The TV Show - S5E11

#3 - Paris & Tara (Season 5 - Episode 11)


Paris enlists Nev and Max to help her figure out who has been catfishing her for the past four years. But as the guys investigate, they make a shocking discovery that casts suspicion onto Paris herself!

The episode was rated 6.97 from 223 votes.

Catfish: The TV Show - S7E19

#2 - Mike & Joey (Season 7 - Episode 19)

Co-host Jane Carrey teams up with Nev to help aspiring sugar baby Mike choose between his Los Angeles life of leisure and his deep affection for a mechanic he met on Grindr.

The episode was rated 6.85 from 81 votes.

Catfish: The TV Show - S8E57

#1 - William & Breezy (Season 8 - Episode 57)


William was once a catfish, but now returns as a hopeful looking for love; Nev and Kamie ditch Zoom and hit the streets to help William find out if he has got a shot at romance or if he's about to get a taste of his own medicine.

The episode was rated 6.85 from 39 votes.

Search for TV shows...

About Series with Sophie

Welcome to our community!

We are a community of women who are passionate about our favorite series and want to share that passion with others.

Our mission is to create a space where women can discover new content, connect with like-minded individuals, and engage in meaningful discussions about the series we love.

We believe that everyone should have access to reliable and trustworthy information about their favorite shows, and we strive to be the premier destination for women seeking that information. Whether you're looking for recaps, fan theories, or just want to connect with other fans, we've got you covered.

So join us and be a part of our growing community of series enthusiasts!